Chap. V Of the Product of Acetous Fermentation
Process I.
Substances susceptible of the Acetous Fermentation turned into Vinegar.
The Wine, the Cyder, or the Malt-liquor, which you intend to convert into Vinegar, being first thoroughly mixed with its lees, and with the Tartar it may have deposited, put your liquor into a vat used before, either for making or for holding Vinegar. This vessel must not be quite full, and the external air must have access to the liquor contained in it. Set it where the air may have a degree of warmth answering nearly to the twentieth degree above 0 in Mr. de Réaumur’s Thermometer. Stir the liquor from time to time. There will arise in it a new fermentative motion, accompanied with heat: its vinous odour will gradually change, and turn to a sour smell, which will become stronger and stronger, till the fermentation be finished, and cease of itself. Then stop your vessel close; the liquor it contains will be found converted into Vinegar.
OBSERVATIONS.
All substances that have undergone the spirituous fermentation are capable of being changed into an Acid, by passing through this second fermentation, or this second stage of fermentation. Spirituous liquors, such as Wine, Cyder, Beer, being exposed to a hot air, grow sour in a very short time. Nay, these liquors, though kept with all possible care, in very close vessels, and in a cool place, degenerate at last, change their natures, and insensibly turn sour. Thus the product of spirituous fermentation naturally and spontaneously degenerates to an Acid.
For this reason it is of great importance, in making Wine, or any other vinous liquor, to stop the fermentation entirely, if you desire the Wine should contain as much Spirit as possible. It is even more advantageous to check the fermentation a little before it comes to the height, than afterwards: because the fermentation, though slackened, and in appearance totally ceased, still continues in the vessels; but in a manner so much the less perceptible, as it proceeds more slowly. Thus those liquors, in which the fermentation is not quite finished, but checked, continue for some time to gain more Spirit: whereas, on the contrary, they degenerate and gradually turn sour, if you let the spirituous fermentation go on till it be entirely finished.
The production of the second fermentation, which we are now to consider, is an Acid of so much the greater strength, the stronger and more generous the spirituous liquor, in which it is excited, originally was. The strength of this Acid, commonly called Vinegar, depends likewise, in a great measure, on the methods used in fermenting the vinous liquor, in order to convert it into Vinegar: for if it be fermented in broad, flat vessels, and left to grow sour of itself, the spirituous part will be dissipated, and the liquor, though sour indeed, will be vapid and effete.
The Vinegar-makers, to increase the strength of their Vinegar, use certain methods of which they make a mystery, keeping them very secret. However, Mr. Boerhaave gives us, from some Authors, the following description of a process for making Vinegar.
“Take two large oaken Vats or Hogsheads, and in each of these place a wooden grate or hurdle, at the distance of a foot from the bottom. Set the vessel upright, and on the grates place a moderately close layer of green twigs, or fresh cuttings of the vine. Then fill up the vessel with the foot-stalks of grapes, commonly called the Rape, to within a foot of the top of the vessel, which must be left quite open.
“Having thus prepared the two vessels, pour into them the Wine to be converted into Vinegar, so as to fill one of them quite up, and the other but half full. Leave them thus for twenty-four hours, and then fill up the half-filled vessel, with liquor from that which is quite full, and which will now in its turn be left only half-full. Four and twenty hours afterwards repeat the same operation, and thus go on, keeping the vessels alternately full and half-full, during every twenty-four hours, till the Vinegar be made. On the second or third day there will arise, in the half-filled vessel, a fermentative motion, accompanied with a sensible heat, which will gradually increase from day to day. On the contrary, the fermenting motion is almost imperceptible in the full vessel; and as the two vessels are alternately full and half-full, the fermentation is by that means, in some measure, interrupted, and is only renewed every other day, in each vessel.
“When this motion appears to be entirely ceased, even in the half-filled vessel, it is a sign that the fermentation is finished; and therefore the vinegar is then to be put into common casks, close stopped, and kept in a cool place.
“A greater or less degree of warmth accelerates or checks this, as well as the spirituous fermentation. In France it is finished in about fifteen days, during the summer; but if the heat of the air be very great, and exceed the twenty-fifth degree of Mr. de Réaumur’s Thermometer, the half-filled vessel must be filled up every twelve hours; because, if the fermentation be not so checked in that time, it will become so violent, and the liquor will be so heated, that many of the spirituous parts, on which the strength of the Vinegar depends, will be dissipated; so that nothing will remain, after the fermentation, but a vapid wash, sour indeed, but effete. The better to prevent the dissipation of the spirituous parts, it is a proper and usual precaution to close the mouth of the half-filled vessel, in which the liquor ferments, with a cover made also of oak-wood. As to the full vessel, it is always left open, that the air may act freely on the liquor it contains: for it is not liable to the same inconveniencies, because it ferments but very slowly.”
The vine-cuttings and grape-stalks, which the Vinegar-makers put into their vessels, serve to increase the strength of the liquor. These matters contain a very manifest and perceptible Acid. They also serve as a ferment; that is, they dispose the Wine to become eager more expeditiously, and more vigorously. They are the better, and the more efficacious, for having been once used, because they are thereby thoroughly drenched with the fermented Acid: and therefore the Vinegar-makers lay them by, for preparing other Vinegar, after washing them nimbly in running water, in order to free them from a viscid oily matter, which settles on them during the fermentation. This matter must by all means be removed; because it is disposed to grow mouldy and rot; so that it cannot but be prejudicial to any liquor into which you put it.
As the Acetous fermentation differs from the Spirituous in its production, so it doth in many circumstances attending it. 1. Motion and agitation are not prejudicial to the Acetous fermentation, as they are to the Spirituous; on the contrary, moderate stirring, provided it be not continual, is of service to it. 2. This fermentation is accompanied with remarkable heat; whereas, the warmth of the spirituous fermentation is scarce sensible. 3. I do not believe there ever was an instance of the vapour that rises from a liquor in Acetous fermentation proving noxious, and producing either disorders or sudden death, as the vapour of fermenting Wine doth. 4. Vinegar deposites a viscid oily matter, as hath just been observed, very different from the Lees and Tartar of Wine. Vinegar never deposites any Tartar; even though new Wine, that hath not yet deposited its Tartar, should be used in making it.
The following processes will give us occasion to treat of the nature of Vinegar, and the principles of which it consists.
Process II
To concentrate Vinegar by Frost.
Expose to the air, in frosty weather, the Vinegar you desire to concentrate. Icicles will form in it; but the whole liquor will not freeze. Take out those icicles: and if you desire a further concentration of your Vinegar by this method, the liquor which did not freeze the first time must be exposed to a stronger frost. More icicles will form therein, which must likewise be separated, and kept by themselves. The liquor which doth not freeze this second time will be a very strong concentrated Vinegar.
OBSERVATIONS.
Liquors, replete with an Acid, freeze with much more difficulty than pure water. Thus, if a very aqueous acid liquor be exposed to frost, some of the water in the liquor will presently freeze; while the rest, being rendered more acid by the separation of the frozen phlegm, will remain fluid, and resist the degree of cold which freezes water. Now Vinegar, being an acid liquor containing much water, may therefore be highly concentrated by freezing its phlegm in this manner; and the more icicles you get from it, the stronger and more active will the remaining Vinegar be.
Mr. Stahl was the first, I believe, who thus made use of congelation, for procuring a very strong Acid of Vinegar. Mr. Geoffroy hath since taken the same method. A curious and circumstantial account of his experiments, on this subject, are printed in the Memoirs of the Academy for 1739.
As it was excessive cold in the winter of that year, Mr. Geoffroy took the opportunity of exposing to the frost several Vinegars of different strengths; and he determined the degree of Acidity in each, both before and after their concentration, in order to compare them, and discover how much stronger each Vinegar was rendered by the freezing of the aqueous part. To determine the strength of the Vinegars, he made use of the method pointed out by Mr. Homberg and Mr. Stahl. This method consists in combining to the exact point of saturation, a certain quantity of Vinegar with well-dried Salt of Tartar. The more Salt of Tartar is required, to absorb and perfectly neutralize the Vinegar, the stronger it must be reckoned; because the quantity of Alkali necessary to constitute a Neutral Salt is always proportioned to the quantity of Acid in that Salt.
One of the Vinegars employed in Mr. Geoffroy’s experiments, two drams of which were entirely absorbed by six grains of Salt of Tartar, having been concentrated by once freezing, and thereby reduced from eighteen quarts to six, he found it so increased in strength, that two drams thereof required twenty-four grains of Salt of Tartar to absorb them.
The first icicles that separate from Vinegar, in this process, are perfectly clear, and as insipid as water. As the Vinegar becomes more concentrated, the plates of ice becoming thinner, more spongy, and flaky like snow, retain between them some portion of the Acid; and it is proper to begin to save them as soon as they appear to be sensibly acid.
Mr. Geoffroy carried the concentration of Vinegar as far as the cold of that winter in 1739 would allow him; and eight quarts of Vinegar, already concentrated by frost in the preceding years, being reduced to two quarts and a half by the frost of the 19th of January, the coldest day of that year, was found to be so strong, that two drams thereof required forty-eight grains of Salt of Tartar to absorb them. The icicles of this Vinegar, being thawed, retain so much strength as to require thirteen grains of the Salt of Tartar to absorb them.
Vinegar suffers no decomposition by the congelation of its phlegm, and the consequent concentration of its Acid. What is left still contains all the principles of which Vinegar consists. Its principles are only brought nearer together, and into a smaller compass: and for this reason it grows the thicker the more it is concentrated. When therefore you desire to concentrate the Acid of Vinegar, and at the same time to purify it, that is, to free it from some of its oil and earth, you must have recourse to distillation.
Wine, as well as Vinegar, may be concentrated by freezing. Mr. Stahl exposed several sorts of Wine to the frost, and by that means separated from them about two thirds, or three quarters, of almost pure phlegm. The remainders of the Wines so concentrated were of a somewhat thickish consistence. They were very strong, and kept for several years without altering, in places where the free access of the air, alternately cold and hot according to the seasons, would have soured, or spoiled, any other kind of Wine in the space of a few weeks.
Wine thus concentrated by freezing is not thereby decomposed, any more than Vinegar: it is only dephlegmated. By the addition of as much water as was separated from it, you may restore it to its former condition; in which respect it differs greatly from the residue of Wine whose spirituous part, with a proportion of its phlegm, hath been drawn off by distillation: for though you mix that residue again with the principles you separated from it, you can never make Wine of it again; the spirituous part being no longer in a capacity to combine with the other principles of the Wine, in the same manner as before that separation. And this shews that heat, besides separating the most volatile parts, produces moreover a considerable change in the disposition of those which did not rise in the first distillation.
Since the above experiments were made by Messrs. Stahl and Geoffroy, concentration by freezing is pretty frequently practised in laboratories; but on Vinegar only, seldom on Wine: because, when Vinegar is thus concentrated, a much stronger Acid is more easily and more expeditiously obtained from it, as will be shewn in the following process; whereas the distillation, as well as the quality, of Spirit of Wine is much the same, whether the Wine it is obtained from be concentrated or no. The reason of this difference is, that Spirit of Wine, being very light, rises in distillation before the phlegm; whereas the Acid of Vinegar, being much more ponderous, rises only at the same time with the aqueous part, or even after it.
Process III
Vinegar analyzed by Distillation.
Into a glass or stone cucurbit put the Vinegar to be distilled; fit to it a glass head; place your alembic in the sand-bath of a distilling furnace, and lute on a receiver. Apply a very gentle heat at first. A clear, limpid, light liquor will rise, and fall in distinct drops, like water, from the nose of the alembic.
Continue distilling this first liquor, till the vinegar contained in the cucurbit be diminished about a fourth part. Then shift your receiver, and increase the fire a little. A clear liquor will still come over, but heavier and more acid than the former. Distil in this manner, till you have drawn off, into your second receiver, two-thirds of the liquor that was left in the cucurbit.
A thick matter will now remain at the bottom of the still: put it into a retort; lute on a receiver; set your retort in a reverberating furnace, and distil with degrees of fire. There will come over a limpid liquor, very acid and sharp, yet ponderous, and requiring a great degree of fire to raise it; on which account it makes the receiver very hot. It hath a strong empyreumatic smell. When the distillation begins to slacken, increase your fire. There will rise an Oil of a fetid, quick smell. At last, when nothing more will rise with the strongest fire, break the retort, and in it you will find a black charred matter: burn it, and from the ashes lixiviated with water you will obtain a Fixed Alkali.
OBSERVATIONS.
None of the liquors that come over in this operation, before the last fetid Oil, seem to have any other properties than those of an oily Acid; none of them is inflammable, none of them resembles Spirit of Wine; but all of them being thrown into the fire extinguish it. Mr. Boerhaave however takes notice, that a Chymist, named Vigani, affirms the first portion of the liquor which rises in the distillation of Vinegar to be inflammable, and no other than Spirit of Wine. Mr. Boerhaave suspected that this might happen from Vigani’s having distilled Vinegar too newly made; and found upon trial that Vinegar, being distilled soon after it was made, yielded at first in distillation a certain quantity of an Ardent Spirit; but that the same thing did not happen in the distillation of old Vinegar. And this proves that fermentation hath the same effect on Vinegar as on Wine; that is, that though the fermentation which produces these liquors seems to be over in a certain time, when the violent intestine commotion ceases, yet it still continues in the vessels for a considerable time after, though it be imperceptible. Thus, the portion of Ardent Spirit, obtained from some Vinegars, comes from a small quantity of Wine, which still remains unchanged in these Vinegars, not having had time enough to turn sour. For it is certain, from the experiments of all other Chymists as well as Mr. Boerhaave, that Vinegar, when old enough, yields no Ardent Spirit in distillation.
But though old and well-made Vinegar yields no Ardent Spirit in distillation, we cannot thence conclude that it contains none. On the contrary, there are experiments which demonstrate that some of the Ardent Spirit, which was in the Wine before it was turned into Vinegar, still remains; but probably so combined and blended with the acid part, that it cannot be separated and rendered perceptible but by peculiar processes.
Mr. Geoffroy obtained an Ardent Spirit from Vinegar, by distilling it as soon as it was concentrated by freezing. “This spirit,” says he16, “is the first liquor that rises. At first it hath only the same degree of inflammability as brandy; but, when re-distilled in the balneum mariæ, it fires gun-powder, like the best rectified Spirit of Wine: with this difference, that our Spirit is impregnated with an oil of an acrid taste and empyreumatic smell, which makes it yellow, and imparts its odour to it. This Spirit, at least that which comes over first, retains none of the Acid of the Vinegar; seeing it neither changes the tincture of violets, nor effervesces with Salt of Tartar.”
Mr. Geoffroy observes, that, if Vinegar concentrated by freezing be afterwards kept for several years, no Ardent Spirit will then be obtained from it by distillation. And this confirms what we said of unconcentrated Vinegar, and gives reason to think that the Ardent Spirit obtained from Vinegar, either by distilling it after concentration by freezing, or by other processes of which we shall treat in the sequel, is foreign to the Vinegar, and is only found therein, as was said above, because Vinegar contains a certain quantity of Wine which hath not altered its nature. For the Spirit of Wine we obtain from Vinegar doth not hinder our obtaining from it a great deal of Acid, which being more ponderous rises after it. Mr. Geoffroy gives the following account of the sequel of his analysis of Vinegar by distillation.
“Continuing to distil in a balneum mariæ the concentrated Vinegar, of which I had employed four pounds two ounces, there was left, after the distillation, a residuum of fourteen ounces; which could not rise, because it was too thick. I found it covered with a saline crust, which is the true Essential Salt of Vinegar, and not of the same nature with Tartar: for Tartar of Wine is scentless; whereas the Salt of Vinegar hath a pungent smell, being the Acid of Tartar subtilized by its union with the Sulphureous parts. If a sand-bath be now used, instead of the balneum mariæ, to carry on the distillation without burning the matter, part of this Salt will be resolved, and yield the last Acid Spirit, which is the strongest that can be obtained.
“After I had, by a sand-heat, extracted all the Acid Spirit that the several residuums put together would yield, I found at the bottom of the cucurbit a brown mass, of the consistence of a pretty solid extract. Of this I put into a retort two pounds, together with six pounds of sand well washed and very dry; and, applying a graduated heat, I first obtained six ounces of an Acid Spirit, that smelt very strong of the empyreuma, and was a little coloured with some portion of oil; seven ounces of Spirit, having a volatile urinous smell, came over next: at last the white vapours appeared more and more dense. A volatile concrete Salt adhered to the sides of the ballon, and I found four ounces of a thick fetid Oil floating on the Spirit. The concrete volatile Salt, when collected, weighed two drams. The black matter remaining in the bottom of the retort, being calcined and lixiviated, yielded a fat alkaline Salt, which it is almost impossible to dry.”
I have given this account of Mr. Geoffroy’s analysis of Vinegar at length, only because it differs in several respects from that described in the process, which is Mr. Boerhaave’s, as well as from those delivered by several other Authors, who make no mention either of the saline matter, which Mr. Geoffroy found on the residuum of Vinegar, after its first distillation in the balneum mariæ, or of the volatile urinous Spirit and Salt, which he obtained from that residuum.
These differences may arise either from the manner of distilling the Vinegar, or from Mr. Geoffroy’s Vinegar having been concentrated by freezing, or rather from the quantity, and, above all, from the age of the Vinegar, examined by those different Chymists.
The distillation of Vinegar serves not only to separate its Acid from a considerable quantity of earth and oily parts, with which it is entangled, but also to dephlegmate and concentrate it. Yet Mr. Lemeri affirms, that Vinegar is not distilled with a view to dephlegmate it. He condemns the common method of throwing away the first runnings as useless phlegm, and saving only what comes off afterwards; having, he says, observed, that the phlegm of Vinegar cannot be abstracted, like that of many other acid liquors, and that what comes over first is almost as sharp as what rises afterwards, be the fire applied at first ever so small.
There is reason to think that Mr. Lemeri did not carefully enough examine the strength of his Spirit of Vinegar, at the different stages of his distillation: for Mr. Geoffroy, in the Memoir above cited, gives an account of a distillation of Vinegar, the product whereof he examined with care, having for that purpose divided it into five different portions: and his experiments put it beyond all doubt, that the first portions of Spirit of Vinegar are far from being so acid as the last. This Vinegar was so strong before distillation, that it required six grains of Salt of Tartar to absorb two drams of it. Two drams of the first portion of his Spirit were absorbed by three grains only of Salt of Tartar: the Acid of the second portion took five grains to absorb it. (Each experiment was made with two drams of Vinegar). The third portion was absorbed by ten grains; the fourth by thirteen, and the fifth took no less than nineteen: which proves that Vinegar, like most other Acids, may be concentrated by distilling off the most aqueous part, which is lighter than the Acid.
There are therefore two ways of concentrating Vinegar, and separating its most acid part, namely distillation and congelation. These two methods may be successively applied to the same Vinegar, and a very powerful Acid obtained by their concurrence. Mr. Geoffroy having exposed to the frost, on the 19th of January 1739, the last russet-coloured liquor, drawn from the residuum of distilled Vinegar, found it so concentrated thereby, that it required sixty grains of Salt of Tartar to absorb two drams of it.