Better Gutenberg
Free, beautifully formatted public-domain ebooks

Physiological Economy in Nutrition

by Russell H. Chittenden

6 of 19 · Contents · Download EPUB

Thursday, June 23, 1904

Breakfast.—Coffee 123 grams, cream 50 grams, sugar 11 grams.

Lunch.—Omelette 50 grams, French fried potatoes 70 grams, bacon 10 grams, wheat gems 43 grams, butter 9 grams, strawberries 125 grams, sugar 20 grams, cream cake 59 grams.

Dinner.—Beefsteak 34 grams, peas 60 grams, creamed potato 97 grams, bread 26 grams, butter 17 grams, lettuce-orange salad 153 grams, crackers 43 grams, cream cheese 15 grams, coffee 53 grams, sugar 12 grams.

Food.Grams.Per cent Nitrogen.Total Nitrogen.
Coffee123 + 53 =176×0.045=0.079gram.
Cream50×0.35=0.175
Sugar11 + 20 + 12 =43×0.00=0.000
Omelette50×1.32=0.660
French fried potatoes70×0.37=0.259
Bacon10×3.43=0.343
Wheat gems43×1.49=0.641
Butter9 + 17 =26×0.13=0.034
Strawberries125×0.11=0.138
Cream cake59×0.98=0.578
Beefsteak34×4.14=1.408
Peas60×0.97=0.582
Creamed potato97×0.34=0.330
Bread26×1.23=0.320
Lettuce-orange salad153×0.15=0.230
Crackers43×1.40=0.602
Cream cheese15×1.62=0.243
Total nitrogen in food6.622grams.
Total nitrogen in urine5.260

Fuel value of the food 1863 calories.

Friday, June 24, 1904.

Breakfast.—Coffee 96 grams, sugar 8 grams, milk 32 grams.

Lunch.—Creamed codfish 89 grams, baked potato 95 grams, butter 10 grams, hominy gems 58 grams, strawberries 86 grams, sugar 26 grams, ginger snaps 47 grams.

Dinner.—Cold tongue 14 grams, fried potato 48 grams, peas 60 grams, wheat gems 30 grams, butter 11 grams, lettuce-orange salad with mayonnaise dressing 155 grams, crackers 22 grams, cream cheese 14 grams, ginger snaps 22 grams, coffee 58 grams, sugar 10 grams.

Food.Grams.Per cent Nitrogen.Total Nitrogen.
Coffee123 + 53 =176×0.045=0.079gram.
Sugar8 + 26 + 10 =44×0.00=0.000
Milk32×0.51=0.163
Creamed codfish89×1.78=1.584
Baked potato95×0.29=0.276
Butter10 + 11 =21×0.13=0.027
Hominy gems58×1.20=0.696
Strawberries86×0.11=0.095
Ginger snaps47 + 22 =69×1.15=0.794
Cold tongue14×4.87=0.682
Fried potato48×0.37=0.178
Peas60×0.94=0.564
Wheat gems30×1.45=0.435
Lettuce-orange salad, etc.155×0.15=0.233
Crackers22×1.40=0.308
Cream cheese14×1.62=0.227
Total nitrogen in food6.331grams.
Total nitrogen in urine5.300

Fuel value of the food 1506 calories.

Saturday, June 25, 1904.

Breakfast.—Coffee 101 grams, milk 36 grams, sugar 13 grams.

Lunch.—Omelette 50 grams, bacon 9 grams, French fried potato 23 grams, biscuit 29 grams, butter 8 grams, cream cheese 17 grams, iced tea 150 grams, sugar 15 grams, ginger snaps 42 grams.

Dinner.—Wheat popovers 57 grams, butter 10 grams, lettuce-orange salad with mayonnaise dressing 147 grams, cream cheese 21 grams, crackers 22 grams, cottage pudding 82 grams, coffee 48 grams, sugar 11 grams.

Food.Grams.Per cent Nitrogen.Total Nitrogen.
Coffee1201 + 48 =149×0.045=0.067gram.
Milk36×0.46=0.166
Sugar13 + 15 + 11 =39×0.00=0.000
Omelette50×1.42=0.710
Bacon9×2.66=0.239
French fried potato23×0.57=0.131
Biscuit29×1.35=0.392
Butter8 + 10 =18×0.13=0.023
Iced tea150×0.018=0.027
Ginger snaps42×1.15=0.483
Cream cheese17 + 21 =38×1.62=0.616
Wheat popovers57×1.64=0.935
Lettuce-orange salad147×0.15=0.221
Crackers22×1.40=0.308
Cottage pudding82×0.76=0.623
Total nitrogen in food4.941grams.
Total nitrogen in urine4.430

Fuel value of the food 1392 calories.

Sunday, June 26, 1904.

Breakfast.—Coffee 122 grams, cream 31 grams, sugar 8 grams.

Dinner.—Roast lamb 50 grams, baked potato 52 grams, peas 64 grams, biscuit 32 grams, butter 12 grams, lettuce salad 43 grams, cream cheese 21 grams, toasted crackers 23 grams, blanc mange 164 grams.

Supper.—Iced tea 225 grams, sugar 29 grams, lettuce sandwich 51 grams, strawberries 130 grams, sugar 22 grams, cream 40 grams, sponge cake 31 grams.

Food.Grams.Per cent Nitrogen.Total Nitrogen.
Coffee122×0.045=0.055gram.
Cream31 + 40 =71×0.32=0.227
Sugar8 + 26 + 10 =44×0.00=0.000
Roast lamb50×4.28=2.140
Baked potato52×0.29=0.151
Peas64×1.04=0.666
Biscuit32×1.35=0.432
Butter12×0.13=0.016
Lettuce salad43×0.23=0.099
Cream cheese21×1.62=0.340
Toasted crackers23×1.36=0.313
Blanc mange164×0.35=0.574
Iced tea225×0.018=0.041
Lettuce sandwich51×0.85=0.434
Strawberries130×0.11=0.143
Sponge cake31×0.94=0.291
Total nitrogen in food5.922grams.
Total nitrogen in urine4.660

Fuel value of the food 1533 calories.

Monday, June 27, 1904.

Breakfast.—Coffee 112 grams, cream 22 grams, sugar 10 grams.

Lunch.—Roast lamb 9 grams, baked potato 90 grams, wheat gems 47 grams, butter 12 grams, sugar 25 grams, iced tea 250 grams, vanilla éclair 47 grams.

Dinner.—Lamb chop 32 grams, asparagus 49 grams, butter 17 grams, creamed potato 107 grams, bread 35 grams, lettuce-orange salad with mayonnaise dressing 150 grams, cream cheese 12 grams, crackers 21 grams, coffee 63 grams, sugar 9 grams.

Food.Grams.Per cent Nitrogen.Total Nitrogen.
Coffee123 + 53 =176×0.045=0.079gram.
Cream22×0.32=0.070
Sugar10 + 25 + 9 =44×0.00=0.000
Iced tea250×0.018=0.045
Baked potato90×0.25=0.225
Wheat gems47×1.65=0.776
Butter12 + 17 =29×0.13=0.038
Roast lamb9×4.28=0.385
Vanilla éclair47×0.85=0.400
Lamb chops32×4.57=1.462
Asparagus49×0.59=0.289
Creamed potato107×0.40=0.428
Bread35×1.33=0.466
Lettuce-orange salad, etc.150×0.23=0.345
Cream cheese12×1.62=0.194
Crackers21×1.35=0.284
Total nitrogen in food5.486grams.
Total nitrogen in urine4.980

Fuel value of the food 1454 calories.

NITROGEN BALANCE.—Chittenden.

Nitrogen
Taken in.
Output.
Nitrogen in Urine.Weight of Fæces (dry).
June236.622grams.5.26grams.10.6grams.
246.3315.300.7
254.9414.4314.2
265.9224.6611.9
275.4864.9815.2
82.6grams contain
6.08% N.
29.30224.63+5.022grams nitrogen.
29.302grams nitrogen.29.652grams nitrogen.
Nitrogen balance for five days=-0.350gram.
Nitrogen balance per day=-0.070gram.

Average Intake.

Calories per day1549.
Nitrogen per day5.860 grams.

Examination of these figures makes quite clear that the body was still in nitrogen equilibrium, or essentially so, the minus balance being so small as to have little significance. The body-weight was still stationary, and yet during this balance period the average daily intake of nitrogen was only 5.86 grams, corresponding to 36.62 grams of proteid or albuminous food. Further, the average daily fuel value of the food was only 1549 calories, a trifle less than in the preceding period. The average daily output of nitrogen through the urine for this period was 4.92 grams, corresponding to the metabolism of 30.7 grams of proteid food. Hence, the results of this period confirm those of the preceding period and make it quite clear that this subject, with a body-weight of 57.5 kilos, can be maintained in body equilibrium, and in nitrogen equilibrium, on a daily diet containing only 5.8 grams of nitrogen and with a fuel value of about 1600 calories. Under these conditions, as in the last balance period, the daily amount of nitrogen metabolized was very small, averaging only 4.92 grams. Comparison of this figure with the accepted standard of 16 grams of nitrogen makes quite clear the extent of the physiological economy which is attainable by the body, and emphasizes also the extent of the unnecessary and worse than useless labor put upon the body by the prevalent dietetic habits of the majority of mankind.

It is of course understood that the low fuel value which sufficed to keep the writer in body equilibrium would not meet the requirements of a more active life, with greater physical labor. The writer has led a very busy life during the year of this experiment, but it has been mental activity rather than physical, although doubtless he has exercised as much as the ordinary professional worker not accustomed to athletic sports. The results of the experiment, however, make it quite clear that a man of the above body-weight, even though he lead a very active life—not involving great physical labor—can maintain his body in equilibrium indefinitely with an intake of 36 to 40 grams of proteid or albuminous food, and with a total fuel value of about 1600 calories. Further, it is to be understood that there is no special form of diet involved in the accomplishment of such a result. Scrutiny of the daily diet, tabulated in the two balance periods, will show the character of the food made use of. Personal likes and dislikes must naturally enter into the choice of any diet, and freedom of choice, freedom to follow the dictates of one’s appetite, with such regulation as comes from the use of reason and intelligence, are all that is necessary to secure the desired end. Physiological economy in nutrition is easily attainable and does not involve the adoption of vegetarianism. It does mean, however, temperance and simplicity in diet, coupled with intelligent regulation, which, however, soon becomes a habit and eventually leads to a moderation in diet which fully satisfies all the cravings of appetite as completely as it suffices to maintain the body in equilibrium and in a general condition of health and vigor.

Taking the data recorded above, we may now calculate the nitrogen requirement of the body per kilo of body-weight. With the body-weight placed at 57 kilos and with an average daily elimination of nitrogen for nearly nine months of 5.699 grams, or practically 5.7 grams, it is evident that the nitrogen metabolized per kilo of body-weight in the present instance was exactly 0.1 gram. If we take the lower figure of 5.40 grams of nitrogen, the average daily excretion from April 13 to June 27, we find the nitrogen requirement to be 0.0947 gram per kilo of body-weight. Translating these figures into terms of proteid or albuminous matter, they mean the utilization or metabolism of 0.625 gram of proteid matter daily per kilo of body-weight, under the conditions of life, activity, and general food consumption prevailing throughout this period of nearly nine months with this particular individual.

Whether we are justified in saying that this figure represents the minimal proteid requirement of this particular individual is perhaps questionable, since the proteid or nitrogen requirement will of necessity vary somewhat with the amount of non-nitrogenous food consumed. Doubtless, the nitrogen metabolism could be reduced still lower by increasing the intake of non-nitrogenous food, but under the above conditions of life, following a plan of living both congenial and satisfactory, one that fully sufficed to keep the body in equilibrium and with the practice of a general physiological economy, we may say that the metabolism of 0.1 gram of nitrogen per kilo of body-weight was quite sufficient to meet all the requirements of the body. Health, strength, mental and physical vigor have been maintained unimpaired, and there is a growing conviction that in many ways there is a distinct improvement in both the physical and mental condition. Greater freedom from fatigue, greater aptitude for work, greater freedom from minor ailments, have gradually become associated in the writer’s mind with this lowered proteid metabolism and general condition of physiological economy. The writer, however, is fully alive to the necessity of caution in the acceptance of one’s feelings as a measure of physical or mental condition, but he has been keenly watchful for any and every sign or symptom during the course of these experiments, and is now strongly of the opinion that there is much good to be gained in the adoption of dietetic habits that accord more closely with the true physiological needs of the body. If a man of 57 kilos body-weight can maintain a condition of equilibrium, with continuance of health, strength, and vigor (to say nothing of possible improvement), with a daily consumption of say 40 grams of proteid food and sufficient non-nitrogenous food to yield 2000 calories, why should he load up his system each day with three times this amount of proteid food, with enough more fat and carbohydrate to yield 3000 plus calories?

Finally, the writer in summing up his own experience is inclined to say that while he entered upon this experiment simply with a view to studying the question from a purely scientific and physiological standpoint, he has become so deeply impressed with the great gain to the body by this practice of physiological economy, and his system has become so accustomed to the new level of nutrition that there is no desire to return to the more liberal dietetic habits of former years.


Obviously, it is not wise nor safe to draw too broad deductions from a single individual, nor from a single experiment even though it extends over a long period of time; consequently, we may turn our attention to other individuals with presumably different personality and different habits of life. The writer’s colleague, Dr. Lafayette B. Mendel, Professor of Physiological Chemistry in the Sheffield Scientific School, kindly volunteered to become a subject of experiment. With a body-weight of 76 kilos, 32 years of age, and of strong physique, he commenced to modify his diet about the middle of October, 1903, diminishing gradually the amount of proteid food with the results shown in the following tables, where are given, as in the preceding experiment, the amounts of nitrogen in the urine, as a measure of the quantity of proteid metabolized, uric acid, and other factors of interest in this connection.

The collection of data commenced on October 26, 1903. During some weeks the urine of each day was not analyzed by itself, but an aliquot part was taken from the 24 hours’ quantity, and at the end of a week the determinations were made on the mixture, thereby giving the average daily composition for the period. With Dr. Mendel, as in the writer’s case, there was no prescribing of food, but perfect freedom of choice. The appetite was satisfied each day, but with a gradual diminution of proteid food, especially of meat. Dr. Mendel appeared to accomplish the desired end best by keeping up a liberal allowance of non-nitrogenous food, and the total potential energy of the daily diet was not so greatly diminished as in the writer’s case. In other words, he appeared to need more food, but succeeded without great effort in reducing the proteid intake to nearly as low a level as in the preceding experiment. For the period of three months from January 4 to April 3, 1904, the average daily excretion of nitrogen amounted to 6.46 grams, which means the metabolism of 40.37 grams of proteid or albuminous food per day for this quarter of the year.

Mendel

Date.Body-weight.Urine.
Volume. 24 hours.Sp. Gr.Nitrogen.Uric Acid.P₂O₅.
1903kilosc.c.gramsgramgrams
Oct.2676.21310101910.53
2775.01650101613.460.5801.90
2874.5915102311.03
2974.5825102511.480.6291.87
3074.61330101813.17
3174.51045102112.37
Nov.174.51030102010.380.6021.59
2108010179.59
374.5105810168.860.5281.63
474.597510198.66
574.5103010218.900.5141.83
6123010158.11
774.6145010168.18
874.097010197.910.4241.92
974.062010287.72
1074.054310276.600.3901.17
1174.0116010167.03
1274.086310245.370.4221.52
1374.0141010158.12
1474.0126510178.040.4941.94
1674.076010216.93
1774.085010217.340.3931.50
1874.075710206.840.364
1974.072010257.350.4561.25
2074.065510277.230.474
2174.098510217.440.397
2274.559010267.650.3951.20
2374.51100⎫7.00
daily
average
0.410
daily
average
1.72
daily
average
2474.012001017⎪
251030⎪
2674.0850⎬
279351020⎪
2874.58701021⎪
2974.59931017⎭
3074.56501023⎫7.280.4801.80
Dec.174.59601018⎪
27901023⎪
374.08801023⎬
412001016⎪
574.09301021⎪
610801019⎭
773.57901023⎫7.630.4381.91
873.59651025⎪
974.011301017⎪
1073.06301031⎬
1173.09251019⎪
1213951014⎪
1373.010101018⎭
14103010207.73
1573.087510217.88
1662510276.48⎫0.2591.10
1770010277.60⎪
1888010228.39⎪
1993510207.68⎪
20107510197.35⎪
2152310326.37⎬
22145510178.99⎪
2392010218.33⎪
2472510258.56⎪
2586510248.51⎪
2671010277.54⎭
279101026⎫7.640.4381.16
288301026⎪
297301027⎪
306701033⎪
31630⎬
1904⎪
Jan.1550⎪
210301022⎪
310201019⎭
475010215.63⎫0.4361.41
5103010165.31⎪
673.081510235.77⎪
772.793010196.02⎬
873.5113510175.72⎪
972.299510206.39⎪
10117510176.84⎭
1172.0105010176.17⎫0.4431.43
1272.2123010156.71⎪
1371.8125010167.43⎪
1471.8114010157.05⎬
1596510195.99⎪
1686010236.71⎪
17103010185.81⎭
1873010285.74⎫0.4651.48
1982510236.58⎪
20103510216.70⎪
2172510306.96⎬
2281510236.99⎪
2395010186.27⎪
2471.679010255.93⎭
2571.374010275.33⎫0.4291.29
2660010305.44⎪
2796510206.89⎪
28104510156.33⎬
2989510176.28⎪
3070.666010276.53⎪
3190510216.79⎭
Feb.171.769510255.13⎫0.4511.40
295010236.84⎪
3121010198.10⎪
471.598510206.74⎬
5115510206.51⎪
671.1103510196.27⎪
770.876010256.98⎭
870.580010226.29
970.6115010237.520.448
1070.477010226.750.318
1169.252010316.710.458
1269.456510338.240.390
1369.456010307.830.420
1469.269010277.990.447
1569.568010277.50⎫0.420
1699510196.86⎪
17105510185.63⎪
18118510156.11⎬
1971210255.72⎪
2070.5100010217.38⎪
2170.6123510145.93⎭
2290010186.16⎫0.488
2370.284010205.49⎪
2487510175.83⎪
2570.5145010188.09⎬
2670.2148510156.68⎪
27130010135.93⎪
2869.273510225.91⎭
2957510306.21⎫0.462
Mar.197510197.51⎪
270.5124010157.29⎪
3140010136.63⎬
470.2137510167.34⎪
569.9110010177.06⎪
670.096010206.51⎭
770.597010175.53⎫0.413
870.9122010155.56⎪
970.9128510155.70⎪
10100010206.24⎬
1170.8112010175.98⎪
12128510156.55⎪
1370.4111010155.79⎭
1470.069010245.92⎫0.485
1570.6124010177.29⎪
1670.8145010167.47⎪
1770.278010226.41⎬
18123010126.57⎪
1970.178010276.41⎪
2095010206.21⎭
2170.7100510206.36⎫0.527
2270.9152510146.50⎪
2370.682510236.39⎪
2470.455010296.07⎬
25107010186.93⎪
2670.8110010176.40⎪
2770.6111510165.82⎭
2870.2118510156.22⎫0.389
2970.5137010146.58⎪
3070.3118510166.26⎪
3170.3132510135.96⎬
Apr.1106010166.30⎪
270.6111510166.42⎪
370.3129010136.39⎭
470.084510226.44⎫0.3561.54
5111010206.39⎪
6105510227.53⎪
757510276.42⎬
865010316.94⎪
979510267.06⎪
10123010207.01⎭
1185010215.61⎫0.419
12100510186.66⎪
1369510205.75⎪
1469.691010275.79⎬
1570.1100010186.42⎪
1670.9159010166.30⎪
1770.8125010155.25⎭
1870.598510205.79⎫0.453
1970.7123010165.90⎪
2070.5148510145.70⎪
2170.1112510237.09⎬
2270.3166510137.09⎪
2369.893510236.06⎪
2469.7110010186.07⎭
2569.693510215.78⎫0.373
2669.9100010216.18⎪
2770.1129510156.06⎪
2870.0142510135.56⎬
2970.299010226.24⎪
3070.2110010217.32⎪
May170.0138010145.96⎭
269.8105010165.35⎫0.260
369.870010225.46⎪
469.590010196.48⎪
569.675010236.52⎬
669.7112010197.26⎪
7101010206.00⎪
8116510156.01⎭
969.788010205.38⎫0.408
1070.093510195.22⎪
1169.6105010176.05⎪
1269.895010206.15⎬
13106010206.62⎪
1469.5152010156.47⎪
1569.3134510145.65⎭
1669.0123010155.09
1768.477510195.11
1869.266010216.06⎫0.325
1968.690510187.17⎪
2069.468510226.33⎪
2169.1114210186.78⎪
2269.5105510195.70⎪
2369.6105310185.75⎬
2469.889510206.39⎪
2569.490010186.05⎪
2669.772510256.55⎪
2770.070510267.36⎭
2871.0111510208.23⎫0.476
29137010167.83⎬
3069.774010237.10⎭
31113510175.93
June1130010186.86
2142010146.06
369.7144710157.03
4138310165.97
5153010156.43
687010235.53
7101010134.91
881510195.53
986510196.59
1069.7111010156.36
11141010175.95
1269.1151010146.07
13110010165.94
14109010185.43
15138010176.46
1670.0176010146.55
17175510136.63
18107510266.06
1970.0128510166.55
2058510225.44
2159510246.93
2265510237.07
23123010157.45
Daily aver. from Nov. 10, 1903.100110206.530.4191.46

From November 10, 1903, to June 23, 1904, a period of about seven months and a half, the average daily excretion of nitrogen through the urine was 6.53 grams. In other words, throughout this long period the average daily amount of proteid matter metabolized was 40.8 grams, only a little more than one-third the amount called for by the Voit standard. Until February, the body-weight gradually fell, but from the early part of February until the end of the experiment the body-weight remained practically stationary at 70 kilos. Dr. Mendel, however, from the necessities of his daily work in the laboratory was compelled to a much greater degree of physical activity than the subject of the preceding experiment, and consequently required a larger amount of non-nitrogenous food than the latter. Further, owing to his greater physical activity and the necessary variations in this daily activity, it was not so easy at first to attain equilibrium.

On February 9, a balance experiment of six days was commenced, with a careful comparison of the nitrogen intake and output. In the accompanying tables are shown all of the data. By scrutiny of these it will be seen that Dr. Mendel had adopted essentially a vegetarian diet. During this period of six days, however, he was not in nitrogen equilibrium, neither was he strictly in body equilibrium, since there was a distinct tendency for the body to fall off in weight. In this connection it may be mentioned that there is always a tendency during a balance experiment of this character for the subject to eat less than he is ordinarily accustomed to, owing to the tediousness of weighing every particle of food consumed. Further, for the same reason, and to avoid excess of chemical work in the analysis of samples of food, he is inclined to limit his diet to a few articles and thereby unconsciously restricts his intake of food, sometimes disastrously so.

← Back to Physiological Economy in Nutrition

Scroll to Top