Satire II Argument
This Satire, as well as the tenth Satire of Juvenal, is based upon the Second Alcibiades of Plato, which it closely resembles in arrangement as well as sentiment.
The object is the same in all three; to set before as the real opinion which all good and worthy men entertained, even in the days of Pagan blindness, of the manner and spirit in which the deity is to be approached by prayer and sacrifice, and holds up to reprobation and ridicule the groveling and low-minded notions which the vulgar herd, besotted by ignorance and blinded by self-interest, hold on the subject. While we admire the logical subtlety with which Plato leads us to a necessary acknowledgment of the justice of his view, and the thoroughly practical philosophy by which Juvenal would divert men from indulging in prayers dictated by mere self-interest, we must allow Persius the high praise of having compressed the whole subject with a masterly hand into a few vivid and comprehensive sentences.
The Satire consists of three parts. The first is merely an introduction to the subject. Taking advantage of the custom prevalent among the Romans of offering prayers and victims, and receiving presents and congratulatory addresses from their friends, on their birthday, Persius sends a poetical present to his friend Plotius Macrinus, with some hints on the true nature of prayer. He at the same time compliments him on his superiority to the mass of mankind, and especially to those of his own rank, in the view he took of the subject.
In the second part he exposes the vulgar errors and prejudices respecting prayer and sacrifice, and shows that prayers usually offered are wrong, 1st, as to their matter, and 2dly, as to their manner: that they originate in low and sordid views of self-interest and avarice, in ignorant superstition, or the cravings of an inordinate vanity. At the same time he holds up to scorn the folly of those who offer up costly prayers, the fulfillment of which they themselves render impossible, by indulging in vicious and depraved habits, utterly incompatible with the requests they prefer. Lastly, he explains the origin of these sordid and worse than useless prayers. They arise from the impious and mistaken notions formed by men who, vainly imagining that the Deity is even such a one as themselves, endeavor to propitiate his favor in the same groveling spirit, and with the same unworthy offerings with which they would bribe the goodwill of one weak and depraved as themselves; as though, in Plato’s words, an ἐμπορικὴ τέχνη had been established between themselves and heaven. The whole concludes with a sublime passage, describing in language almost approaching the dignity of inspired wisdom, the state of heart and moral feeling necessary to insure a favorable answer to prayers preferred at the throne of heaven.
“Mark this day, Macrinus,1287 with a whiter stone,1288 which, with auspicious omen, augments1289 thy fleeting years.1290 Pour out the wine to thy Genius!1291 Thou at least dost not with mercenary prayer ask for what thou couldst not intrust to the gods unless taken aside. But a great proportion of our nobles will make libations with a silent censer. It is not easy for every one to remove from the temples his murmur and low whispers, and live with undisguised prayers.1292 A sound mind,1293 a good name, integrity”—for these he prays aloud, and so that his neighbor may hear. But in his inmost breast, and beneath his breath, he murmurs thus, “Oh that my uncle would evaporate!1294 what a splendid funeral! and oh that by Hercules’1295 good favor a jar1296 of silver would ring beneath my rake! or, would that I could wipe out1297 my ward, whose heels I tread on as next heir! For he is scrofulous, and swollen with acrid bile. This is the third wife that Nerius is now taking1298 home!”—That you may pray for these things with due holiness, you plunge your head twice or thrice of a morning1299 in Tiber’s eddies,1300 and purge away the defilements of night in the running stream.
Come now! answer me! It is but a little trifle that I wish to know! What think you of Jupiter?1301 Would you care to prefer him to some man! To whom? Well, say to Staius.1302 Are you at a loss indeed? Which were the better judge, or better suited to the charge of orphan children! Come then, say to Staius that wherewith you would attempt to influence the ear of Jupiter. “O Jupiter!”1303 he would exclaim, “O good Jupiter!” But would not Jove himself call out, “O Jove!”
Thinkest thou he has forgiven thee,1304 because, when he thunders, the holm-oak1305 is rather riven with his sacred bolt than thou and all thy house?1306 Or because thou dost not, at the bidding of the entrails of the sheep,1307 and Ergenna, lie in the sacred grove a dread bidental to be shunned of all, that therefore he gives thee his insensate beard to pluck?1308 Or what is the bribe by which thou wouldst win over the ears of the gods? With lungs, and greasy chitterlings? See[1309] some grandam or superstitious1310 aunt takes the infant from his cradle, and skilled in warding off the evil eye,1311 effascinates his brow and driveling lips with middle1312 finger and with lustral spittle, first. Then dandles1313 him in her arms, and with suppliant prayer transports him either to the broad lands of Licinus1314 or the palaces of Crassus.1315 “Him may some king and queen covet as a son-in-law! May maidens long to ravish him! Whatever he treads on may it turn to roses!” But I do not trust prayers to a nurse.1316 Refuse her these requests, great Jove, even though she make them clothed in white!1317
You ask vigor for your sinews,1318 and a frame that will insure old age. Well, so be it. But rich dishes and fat sausages prevent the gods from assenting to these prayers, and baffle Jove himself.
You are eager to amass a fortune, by sacrificing a bull; and court Mercury’s favor by his entrails. “Grant that my household gods may make me lucky! Grant me cattle, and increase to my flocks!” How can that be, poor wretch, while so many cauls of thy heifers melt in the flames? Yet still he strives to gain his point by means of entrails and rich cakes.1319 “Now my land, and now my sheepfold teems. Now, surely now, it will be granted!” Until, baffled and hopeless, his sestertius at the very bottom of his money-chest sighs in vain.
Were I to offer you1320 goblets of silver and presents embossed with rich gold,1321 you would perspire with delight, and your heart, palpitating with joy in your left breast,1322 would force even the tear-drops from your eyes. And hence it is the idea enters1323 your mind of covering the sacred faces of the gods with triumphal gold.1324 For among the Brazen brothers,1325 let those be chief, and let their beards be of gold, who send dreams purged from gross humors. Gold hath expelled the vases of Numa1326 and Saturnian1327 brass, and the vestal urns and the pottery of Tuscany.
Oh! souls bowed down to earth! and void of aught celestial! Of what avail is it to introduce into the temples of the gods these our modes of feeling, and estimate what is acceptable to them by referring to our own accursed flesh.1328 This it is that has dissolved Cassia1329 in the oil it pollutes. This has dyed the fleece of Calabria1330 with the vitiated purple. To scrape the pearl from its shell, and from the crude ore to smelt out the veins of the glowing mass; this carnal nature bids. She sins in truth. She sins. Still from her vice gains some emolument.
Say ye, ye priests! of what avail is gold in sacrifice? As much, forsooth, as the dolls which the maiden bestows on Venus! Why do we not offer that to the gods which the blear-eyed progeny of great Messala can not give even from his high-heaped charger. Justice to god and man enshrined1331 within the heart; the inner chambers1332 of the soul free from pollution; the breast imbued1333 with generous honor. Give me these to present at the temples, and I will make my successful offering1334 with a little meal.1335
Footnotes
1287 Macrine. Nothing is known of this friend of Persius, but from the old Scholiast, who tells us that his name was Plotius Macrinus; that he was a man of great learning, and of a fatherly regard for Persius, and that he had studied in the house of Servilius. Britannicus calls him Minutius Macrinus, and says he was of equestrian rank, and a native of Brixia, now “Brescia.”
1288 Meliore lapillo. The Thracians were said to put a white stone into a box to mark every happy day they spent, and a black stone for every unhappy day, and to reckon up at the end of their lives how many happy days they had passed. Plin., H. N., vii., 40. So Mart., ix., Ep. 53, “Natales, Ovidi, tuos Apriles Ut nostras amo Martias Kalendas; Felix utraque lux diesque nobis Signandi melioribus lapillis.” Hor., i., Od. xxxvi., 10, “Cressâ ne careat pulchra dies notâ.” Plin., Ep. vi., 11, “O Diem lætum notandum mihi candidissimo calculo.” Cat., lxviii., 148, “Quem lapide illa diem candidiore notet.”
1289 Apponit. A technical word in calculating; as in Greek, τιθέναι, and προστιθέναι. So “Appone lucro.” Hor., i., Od. ix., 14.
1290 Annos. For the respect paid by the Romans to their birthdays, see Juv., xi., 83; xii., 1; Pers., vi., 19; and Censorinus, de Die Natali, pass.
1291 Genio. Genius, “a genendo.” The deity who presides over each man from his birth, as some held, being coeval with the man himself. The birthday was sacred to him; the offerings consisted of wine, flowers, and incense. “Manum a sanguine abstinebant: ne die quâ ipsi lucem accepissent, aliis demerent.” Censor, a Varrone. Cf. Serv. ad Virg., Geor., i., 302. Hor., ii., Ep. ii., 187, “Scit Genius natale comes qui temperat astrum, naturæ deus humanæ, mortalis in unumquodque caput;” and ii., Ep. i., 143, “Sylvanum lacte piabant, Floribus et vino Genium memorem brevis ævi.” Cf. Orell., in loc. On other days, they offered bloody victims also to the Genius. “Cras Genium mero Curabis et porco bimestri.” Hor., iii., Od. xvii., 14.
1292 Aperto voto. “To offer no prayer that you would fear to divulge,” according to the maxim of Pythagoras, μετὰ φωνῆς εὔχεο, and that of Seneca, “Sic vive cum hominibus tanquam deus videat: sic loquere cum deo tanquam homines audiant.”
1293 Mens bona. Juv., x., 356, “Orandum est ut sit mens sana in corpore sano.”
1294 Ebullit. “Boil away.”
1295 Hercule. Hercules was considered the guardian of hidden treasure, and as Mercury presided over open gains and profits by merchandise, so Hercules was supposed to be the giver of all sudden and unexpected good fortune; hence called πλουτοδότης. Cf. Hor., ii., Sat. vi., 10, “O si urnam argenti fors quæ mihi monstret ut illi Thesauro invento qui mercenarius agrum illum ipsum mercatus aravit, dives amico Hercule.”
1296 Seria, “a tall, narrow, long-necked vessel, frequently used for holding money.”
1297 Expungam, a metaphor from the military roll-calls, from which the names of all soldiers dead or discharged were expunged.
1298 Ducitur. Casaubon reads “conditur.” Cf. Mart., x., Ep. xliii., “Septima jam Phileros tibi conditur uxor in agro: Plus nulli, Phileros, quam tibi reddit ager.”
1299 Mane. Cf. Tibull., III., iv., 9, “At natum in curas hominum genus omina noctis farre pio placant et saliente sale.” Propert., III., x., 13, “Ac primum purâ somnum tibi discute lymphâ.” The ancients believed that night itself, independently of any extraneous pollution, occasioned a certain amount of defilement which must be washed away in pure water at daybreak. Cf. Virg., Æn., viii., 69, “Nox Ænean somnusque reliquit. Surgit et ætherii spectans orientia Solis Lumina rite cavis undam de flumine palmis Sustulit.” Cf. Theophrast., περὶ δεισιδαιμονιὰς, fin.
1300 Tiberino in gurgite. Cf. Juv., vi., 522, “Hibernum fractâ glacie descendet in amnem, ter matutino Tiberi mergetur et ipsis Vorticibus timidum caput abluet.” Hor., ii., Sat. iii., 290, “Illo mane die quo tu indicis jejunia nudus in Tiberi stabit.” Virg., Æn., ii, 719, “Me attrectare nefas donec me flumine vivo abluero.” Ov., Fast., iv., 655, “Bis caput intonsum fontanâ spargitur undâ.” 315, “Ter caput irrorat, ter tollit in æthera palmas.”
1301 De Jove. Read, with Casaubon, “Est ne ut præponere cures Hunc cuiquam? cuinam?”
1302 Staio. The allusion is probably to Staienus, whom Cicero often mentions as a most corrupt judge. Pro Cluent., vii., 24; in Verr., ii., 32. He is said to have murdered his own wife, his brother, and his brother’s wife. Yet even to such a wretch as this, says Persius, you would not venture to name the wishes you prefer to Jove. Cf. Sen., Ep. x., “Nunc quanta dementia est hominum! Turpissima vota Diis insusurrant, si quis admoverit aurem, conticescent; et quod scire hominem nolunt, deo narrant.”
1303 Jupiter. Cf. Hor., i., Sat. ii., 17, “Maxime, quis non, Jupiter! exclamat simul atque audivit.”
1304 Ignovisse. Cf. Eccles., viii., 11, “Because sentence against an evil work is not executed speedily, therefore the heart of the sons of men is fully set in them to do evil.” Tib., I., ii., 8; ix., 4. Claudian. ad Hadr., 38, seq. Juv., xiii, 10, “Ut sit magna tamen certè lenta ira deorum est.”
1305 Ilex. The idea is taken probably from the well-known lines of Lucretius, vi., 387, “Quod si Jupiter atque alii fulgentia Divei Terrifico quatiunt sonitu cœlestia templa, Et jaciunt ignem quo quoique est quomque voluntas: Quur quibus incautum scelus aversabile quomque est non faciunt, ictei flammas ut fulguris halent Pectore perfixo documen mortalibus acre? Et potius nulla sibi turpi conscius in re volvitur in flammeis innoxius, inque peditur Turbine cœlesti subito correptus et igni.” Lucian parodies it also, τὶ δήποτε τοὺς ἱεροσύλους καὶ λῃστὰς ἀφέντες καὶ τοσούτους ὑβριστὰς καὶ βιαίους καὶ ἐπιόρκους, δρῦν τινὰ πολλάκις κεραυνοῦτε τέχνη λίθον ἢ νεὼς ἱστὸν οὐδὲν ἀδικούσης; Jup. Conf., ii., 638.
1306 Tuque domusque. Probably taken from Homer, εἴπερ γάρ τε καὶ αὐτίκ’ Ὀλύμπιος οὐκ ἐτέλεσσεν, Ἔκ γε καὶ ὀψὲ τελεῖ· σύν τε μεγάλῳ ἀπέτισαν, Σὺν σφῇσι κεφαλῇσι γύναιξί τε καὶ τεκέεσσιν.
1307 Fibris. When any person was struck dead by lightning, the priest was immediately called in to bury the body: every thing that had been scorched by it was carefully collected and buried with it. A two-year old sheep was then sacrificed, and an altar erected over the place and the ground slightly inclosed round. Lucan., viii., 864, “Inclusum Tusco venerantur cæspite fulmen.” Hor., A. P., 471, “An triste bidental moverit incestus.” Juv., vi., 587, “Atque aliquis senior qui publica fulgura condit.” Ergenna, or Ergennas, is the name of some Tuscan soothsayer, who gives his directions after inspecting the entrails; the termination being Tuscan, as Porsenna, Sisenna, Perpenna, etc. Bidental is applied indifferently to the place, the sacrifice, and the person. Bidens is properly a sheep fit for sacrifice, which was so considered when two years old. Hence bidens may be a corruption of biennis; or from bis and dens, because at the age of two years the sheep has eight teeth, two of which project far beyond the rest, and are the criterion of the animal’s age.
1308 Vellere barbam. Alluding to the well-known story of Dionysius of Syracuse. Cf. Sat. i., 133.
1309 Ecce. He now passes on to prayers that result from superstitious ignorance, or over-fondness, and which, as far as the matter is concerned, are equally erroneous with the previous class, though not of the same malicious character. On the fifth day after the birth of an infant, sacrifices and prayers were offered for the child to the deities Pilumnus and Picumnus. Purificatory offerings were made on the eighth day for girls, and on the ninth for boys. The day therefore was called dies lustricus, and nominalis, because the name was given. The Greeks called it ὀνομάτων ἑορτή.
1310 Metuens Divûm, i. e., δεισιδαίμων. “Matetera, quasi Mater altera.”
1311 Urentes. Literally, “blasting, withering.” The belief in the effects of the “evil eye” is as prevalent as ever in Southern Europe. They were supposed to extend even to cattle. “Nescio quis teneros oculus mihi fascinat agnos.” Virg., Ecl., iii., 103. To avert this, they anointed the child with saliva, and suspended amulets of various kinds from its neck.
1312 Infami digito. The middle finger was so called because used to point in scorn and derision. Cf. Juv., x., 53, “Mandaret laqueum mediumque ostenderet unguem.”
1313 Manibus quatit. So Homer (lib. vi.) represents Hector as tossing his child in his arms, and then offering up a prayer for him.
1314 Licinus. Probably the Licinus mentioned in Juv., Sat. i., 109; xiv., 306; the barber and freedman of Augustus, an epigram on whom is quoted by Varro. “Marmoreo Licinus tumulo jacet: at Cato parvo. Pompeius nullo. Quis putet esse deos?” Casaubon supposes the Licinius Stolo mentioned by Livy (vii., 16) to be intended.
1315 Crassi. Cf. Juv., x., 108.
1316 Nutrici. Seneca has the same sentiment, Ep. ix., “Etiamnum optas quæ tibi optavit nutrix, aut pædagogus, aut mater? Nondum intelligis quantum mali optaverint.”
1317 Albata. Those who presided over or attended at sacrifices always dressed in white.
1318 Poscis opem nervis. Persius now goes on to ridicule those who by their own folly render the fulfillment of their prayers impossible; who pray for health, which they destroy by vicious indulgence; for wealth, which they idly squander on the costly sacrifices they offer to render their prayers propitious, and the sumptuous banquets which always followed those sacrifices.
1319 Ferto, a kind of cake or rich pudding, made of flour, wine, honey, etc.
1320 Si tibi. He now proceeds to investigate the cause of these misdirected prayers, and shows that it results from a belief that the deity is influenced by the same motives, and to be won over by the same means, as mortal men. Hence the costly nature of the offerings made and the vessels employed in the service of the temple.
1321 Incusa. Cf. Sen., Ep. v., “Non habemus argentum in quod solidi auri cœlatura descendit.” An incrustation or enchasing of gold was impressed upon vessels of silver. This the Greeks called ἐμπαιστικὴ τέχνη.
1322 Lævo. This is the usual interpretation. It may mean, “in your breast, blinded by avarice and covetousness,” as Virg., Æn., xi., “Si mens non læva fuisset.”
1323 Subiit. Sen., Ep. 115, “Admirationem nobis parentes auri argentique fecerunt: et teneris infusa cupiditas altiùs sedit crevitque nobiscum. Deinde totus populus, in alio discors, in hoc convenit: hoc suspiciunt, hoc suis optant, hoc diis velut rerum humanarum maximum cum grati videri velint, consecrant.”
1324 Auro ovato. It was the custom for generals at a triumph to offer a certain portion of their manubiæ to Capitoline Jove and other deities.
1325 Fratres ahenos. It is said that there were in the temple porch of the Palatine Apollo figures of the fifty Danaides, and opposite them equestrian statues of the fifty sons of Ægyptus; and that some of these statues gave oracles by means of dreams. Others refer these lines to Castor and Pollux: but the words “præcipui sunto” seem to imply a greater number. The passage is very obscure. Casaubon adopts the former interpretation.
1326 Numæ. Numa directed that all vessels used for sacred purposes should be of pottery-ware. Cf. ad Juv., xi., 116.
1327 Saturnia. Alluding to the Ærarium in the temple of Saturn.
1328 Pulpa is properly the soft, pulpy part of the fruit between the skin and the kernel: then it is applied to the soft and flaccid flesh of young animals, and hence applied to the flesh of men. It is used here in exactly the scriptural sense, “the flesh.”
1329 Casiam. Vid. Plin., xiii., 3. Persius seems to have had in his eye the lines in the second Georgic, “Nec varios inhiant pulchra testudine postes Illusasque auro vestes, Ephyreiaque æra; Alba neque Assyrio fucatur lana veneno nec Casiâ, liquidi corrumpitur usus olivi.” Both the epic poet and the satirist, as Gifford remarks, use the language of the old republic. They consider the oil of the country to be vitiated, instead of improved, by the luxurious admixture of foreign spices.
1330 Calabrum. The finest wool came from Tarentum in Calabria. Vid. Plin., H. N., viii., 48; ix., 61; Colum., vii., 2; and from the banks of the Galesus in its neighborhood. Hor., Od., II., vi., 10, “Dulce pellitis ovibus Galesi flumen.” Virg., G., iv., 126. Mart., xii., Ep. 64, “Albi quæ superas oves Galesi.”
1331 Compositum. These lines, as Gifford says, are not only the quintessence of sanctity, but of language. Closeness would cramp and paraphrase would enfeeble their sense, which may be felt, but can not be expressed. Casaubon explains compositum, “animum bene comparatum ad omnia divina humanaque jura.” τὸ εὔτακτον τῆς ψυχῆς πρὸς τὰ θεῖά τε καὶ ἀνθρώπινα δίκαια. It may also imply the “harmonious blending of the two.”
1332 Recessus. So the Greeks used the phrases μυχοὺς διανοίας, ἄδυτα ταμιεῖα διανοίας. Cf. Rom., xi., 16, τὰ κρυπτὰ τῶν ἀνθρώπων.
1333 Incoctum a metaphor from a fleece double-dyed. So Seneca, “Quemadmodum lana quosdam colores semel ducit, quosdam nisi sæpius macerata et recocta non perbibit: sic alias disciplines ingenia cum accepere, protinus præstant: hæc nisi altè descendit, et diù sedit, animum non coloravit, sed infecit, nihil ex his quæ promiserat præstat.” Ep. 71. Cf. Virg., Georg., iii., 307, “Quamvis Milesia magno vellera mutentur Tyrios incocta rubores.”
1334 Litabo. Cf. v., 120, “Soli probi litare dicuntur proprie: sacrificare quilibet etiam improbi.” Litare therefore is to obtain that for which the sacrifice is offered. Vid. Liv., xxxviii., 20, “Postero die sacrificio facto cum primis hostiis litasset.” Plaut., Pœnul., ii., 41, “Tum Jupiter faciat ut semper sacrificem nec unquam litem.” Cf. Lact. ad Stat. Theb., x., 610. Suet., Cæs., 81. Even the heathen could see that the deity regarded the purity of the heart, not the costliness of the offering of the sacrificer. So Laberius, “Puras deus non plenas aspicit manus.” τὸ δαιμονίον μᾶλλον πρὸς τὸ τῶν θυόντων ἠθος ἢ πρὸς τὸ τῶν θυομένων πλῆθος βλέπει. Cf. Plat., Alc., II., xii., fin., “Est litabilis hostia bonus animus et pura mens et sincera sententia.” Min., Fel., 32.
1335 Farre. The idea is probably taken from Seneca. Ep. 95, “Nec in victimis, licet opimæ sint, auroque præfulgeant, deorum est honos: sed pia et recta voluntate venerantium: itaque boni etiam farre ac fictili religiosi.” Hor., iii., Od. xxiii., 17, “Immunis aram si tetigit manus non sumptuosa blandior hostia mollivit aversos Penates farre pio et saliente mica.” Cf. Eurip., Fr. Orion εὖ ἴσθ’ ὁτὰν τις εὐσεβῶν θύῃ θεοῖς· κἂν μικρὰ θύῃ τυγχάνει σωτηρίας.