Section IV Immoral Works
Profane,215 indecent,216 seditious,217 and libellous218 books will not be protected. Neither will those which are a fraud upon the public.219 For instance, a book published as translated from the German of Sturm, which was entirely untrue and induced purchasers to buy it, was refused protection.220 Quære whether a piratical book would be protected in so far as it was original. Probably it would.221 If a book is not wholly mischievous, but only in part, it will probably be protected except as to that part;222 and if a book is subsequently published purged of its immoral matter or fraudulent nature it would be protected.223 If an action is brought in respect of a mischievous publication the practice of the Court is to dismiss the action without costs.224 In one case225 Mathew, J., would not take cognisance of immorality mero motu, and when it was not pleaded by the defendant he gave the plaintiff his remedy. Notwithstanding this, there can be no doubt that the Court may refuse to interfere even when both parties are willing to waive the question of immorality. The Court cannot be compelled to sit to take an account between public malefactors.