Chapter X Metronymics
“During the whole evening Mr. Jellyby sat in a corner with his head against the wall, as if he were subject to low spirits.”
(Bleak House, ch. iv.)
Bardsley first drew attention to the very large number of surnames derived from an ancestress. His views have been subjected to much ignorant criticism by writers who, taking upon themselves the task of defending medieval virtue, have been unwilling to accept this terrible picture of the moral condition of England, etc. This anxiety is misplaced. There are many reasons, besides illegitimacy, for the adoption of the mother’s name. In medieval times the children of a widow, especially posthumous children, would often assume the mother’s name. Widdowson itself is sufficiently common. In the case of second marriages the two families might sometimes be distinguished by their mothers’ names. Orphans would be adopted by female relatives, and a medieval Mrs. Joe Gargery would probably have impressed her own name rather than that of her husband on a medieval Pip. In a village which counted two Johns or Williams, and few villages did not, the children of one might assume, or rather would be given by the public voice, the mother’s name. Finally, metronymics can be collected in hundreds by anyone who cares to work through a few early registers.